The short answer
Compare the whole roof: supporting deck, insulation and moisture control, waterproofing, drainage, edges and rooflights. Felt, EPDM and liquid or GRP systems have different specifications and installation requirements. Suitability and detailing matter more than a claim that one material is always best or lasts a fixed number of years.
Begin with what the roof covers and how it will be used
A garage, a heated extension and a roof intended for regular access need different conversations. Tell us about the room below, any condensation concerns, existing rooflights and how people currently reach the roof.
Also describe your plans. If you want to add a rooflight, change the insulation or use the roof as a terrace, mention it before a replacement covering is quoted. A waterproofing renewal should not be mistaken for permission or a design for a new use.
The roof’s existing condition matters too. A material comparison is useful only after understanding whether the deck and retained layers are suitable. Start with the survey, then compare the systems that are appropriate for the proposed scope.
The main waterproofing families in plain English
Modern felt systems commonly use reinforced bitumen membranes; the specification and application method vary. They should not be confused with basic shed felt. [1]
EPDM is a rubber-type single-ply membrane. SPRA guidance treats its fixing, joints and details as parts of a compatible roofing system. [2]
Liquid-applied systems are formed on a prepared substrate. LRWA guidance emphasises compatibility, preparation and application conditions, rather than treating a liquid product as a universal coating. [3]
GRP is a glass-reinforced resin system often described as fibreglass roofing. Ask for the particular system and its requirements, not simply the material family. This overview explains options you may encounter; it is not a claim that every product is suitable for your roof or available within every Prestige quotation.
A practical comparison table
| System | Understand | Ask the contractor |
|---|---|---|
| Reinforced bitumen felt | Specified layers, preparation and application method. | Which complete system is proposed, and how will junctions be finished? |
| EPDM / single ply | Membrane, attachment and compatible joint details. | How will edges, rooflights and penetrations be formed? |
| Liquid-applied / GRP | Substrate suitability, preparation and system-specific conditions. | What testing or deck work is needed before application? |
| Any system | Insulation, drainage and the roof’s intended use. | What is included beyond the visible waterproof layer? |
A useful quote should make these answers specific. If two proposals use different systems, compare their preparation and retained construction as carefully as the product names.
Repair, overlay or replacement: a separate decision
You can choose a suitable material and still have an incomplete refurbishment plan. Ask whether the proposal is a local repair, an overlay on assessed retained layers or a strip-and-renew job. The scope may be more significant than the difference between membrane families.
For an overlay, ask how the existing roof has been assessed and how the new level affects outlets, wall junctions and rooflights. For a replacement, ask which layers are removed and how any concealed deterioration is priced.
Our flat-roof repair planning guide explains that assessment in more detail. If you are comparing costs, make sure the quotations describe the same starting condition and intended outcome.
Drainage and details deserve their own questions
Tell us where water collects or overflows, and whether any previous work changed it. The roof’s drainage route, edges and junctions need to be considered with the covering. A new waterproof surface does not automatically correct every existing arrangement.
Ask what happens around each rooflight, wall junction, pipe or outlet. If those components are retained, understand their condition and the limits of the new work. If they are replaced, have them identified in the specification.
Where the roof covers a heated room, discuss insulation and moisture control before the final build-up is agreed. Changes in thickness can affect surrounding details. These are practical design questions, not optional finishing touches to leave until the material has been ordered.
What affects the cost
The area, shape, number of details, access and amount of removal all matter. So do deck repairs, insulation changes and any other trades required. A simple price per square metre can hide substantial differences between two projects.
Ask for the total including applicable VAT, along with exclusions and provisional work. Compare what is left in place. A cheaper overlay and a replacement including new decking are not equivalent prices for the same job.
Keep guarantee terms in the comparison, but do not choose solely by the longest number of years. Ask who provides the guarantee, which parts it covers, what maintenance is required and how a claim would be made.
Maintenance should fit the finished roof
Ask for a maintenance plan appropriate to the particular system and building. From a safe position, note changes such as debris around visible outlets, new staining or obvious damage. Arrange professional access where closer attention is needed.
Do not assume the surface is suitable for routine walking, storage or furniture. Tell any later contractor what roof system is present and ask how access will be managed. Keep product details and photographs supplied at handover with your property records.
If a concern appears, report the location and what changed. A prompt description is more useful than adding an unknown coating before the original system can be assessed. We can discuss the appropriate next step for your flat roof and property.
Your questions answered
Which flat-roof material is best?
There is no single answer for every building. Compare suitable systems in the context of the deck, insulation, drainage, details and intended use. Ask why a particular complete specification is recommended for your roof.
How long will a new flat roof last?
That depends on the system, design, installation, exposure, use and maintenance. Ask about the applicable guarantee and aftercare, but do not treat a generic lifespan claim as a promise for an unassessed property.
Is a rubber roof always laid in one piece?
The actual arrangement depends on the roof size, shape and specified system. Ask how joints and details will be handled. A headline claim about fewer seams does not explain the rooflight, outlet or perimeter work.
Is GRP suitable for a roof terrace?
Regular use needs a roof designed and specified for that purpose, including structure and protection. The waterproofing material name alone does not establish suitability. Explain the intended use before the work is designed.
Is felt an outdated choice?
Modern reinforced bitumen systems remain a distinct option. The useful comparison is between complete suitable specifications, not between a professional roof system and basic shed felt.
Can I change material when replacing my flat roof?
Potentially, but the existing construction and new system requirements must be considered. Ask what preparation, deck work and detail changes are needed, and compare the complete scope rather than only the new covering.
Sources and further reading
Numbered references support the relevant points above. The guidance here is general; the right specification depends on your property.
- BMI Icopal, How to felt a flat roof.
- Single Ply Roofing Association, Single Ply Roofing: Design Guide, S1/2020 (2020).
- Liquid Roofing and Waterproofing Association, Design Guide for Specifiers: Liquid Applied Waterproofing Systems for Roofs and Balconies (2020).
